A coalition of commercial shippers say plans to create the primary coast-to-coast railroad nonetheless don’t present sufficient information for regulators to make a correct evaluation.
Union Pacific (NYSE: UNP) and Norfolk Southern (NYSE: NSC) in 4 filings have failed to offer fundamental info to permit their transcontinental tie-up to maneuver ahead underneath the Floor Transportation Board’s merger guidelines, shippers declare.
A broad coalition representing chemical producers and industrial shippers in a joint movement filed Thursday with the STB argued that the railroads have failed to offer sufficient info to satisfy the statutory public-interest normal.
“This prima facie threshold is a preliminary display screen primarily based solely on the sufficiency of the proof UP and NS submitted of their software and supplemental filings, considered in essentially the most favorable gentle,” the teams mentioned. “At this stage, the Board doesn’t weigh the energy of the appliance or determine whether or not the merger ought to in the end be authorised. Even when a prima facie case has been made, the deserves of the appliance will solely be weighed after proof and testimony are offered by stakeholders across the nation over the following yr.”
Prima facie is Latin for “on its face,” and is a authorized indication {that a} lawsuit or different matter has sufficient fundamental details to maneuver ahead.
The submitting comes as a rising variety of politicians and different public officers have voiced their opposition to the merger. On the identical time, the Senate at present authorised the renomination of Democrat Karen Hedlund to the STB. Appointed by President Joe Biden in 202, Hedlund’s time period had expired on the finish of 2025. Her new phrases runs by way of Dec. 31, 2030.
The STB rejected as incomplete the preliminary UP-NS merger software in January earlier than conditionally accepting a second submitting in Might whereas requesting extra supporting information. The businesses accomplished these filings in late July.
The STB and predecessor regulators within the postwar period have by no means rejected a merger software twice.
The shipper teams mentioned that the STB itself famous that its evaluation of the latest filings “could embody an analysis as as to if [a]pplicants have offered a prima facie case,” that the proposed merger is in step with the general public curiosity.
The shippers mentioned that the STB’s harder requirements adopted within the early 2000s after a collection of chaotic mergers require any new consolidations to boost competitors, assess downstream results, and supply plans to handle transitional service disruptions, amongst different parts.
Rival railroads and plenty of shippers say that the merger will scale back competitors and lift charges.
“The applying fails to deal with the total vary of aggressive harms, suggest any circumstances to boost competitors for rail shippers, current cheap and documented profit claims, treatment merger-related service failures, or account for the seemingly impression of future mergers,” the shippers mentioned.
The group contains the Alliance for Chemical Distribution; American Chemistry Council; American Gasoline & Petrochemical Producers; the Fertilizer Institut;, and the Nationwide Industrial Transportation League.
Subscribe to BigRig’ Rail e-newsletter and get the newest insights on rail freight proper in your inbox.
Learn extra articles by Editor right here.
Learn extra:
These two industrial classes paced one other sturdy week for rail freight
CPKC earnings larger as income units new second-quarter report
Industrial merchandise spark rail freight positive aspects
BNSF CEO assails new rail merger submitting, says transcon will elevate charges, costs
The submit Rail merger a failure on first sight, shippers protest appeared first on BigRig.


