The brokerage arm of J.B. Hunt gained one and misplaced one in an Arizona federal court docket Thursday in what now’s shaping as much as be one of many key circumstances on dealer legal responsibility because the business strikes to a brand new authorized panorama following the choice in Montgomery vs. Caribe Transport II.
The U.S. District Court docket for Arizona accepted one J.B. Hunt request for abstract judgment within the case of Crystal Gee et. al. vs. J.B. Hunt et. al. Nevertheless it rejected one other.
Plaintiff Crystal Gee is the guardian of the youngsters who had been injured within the crash and left with out their mother and father within the deadly crash that’s the topic of the lawsuit.
The tragedy that led to the lawsuit occurred in October 2023. A truck pushed by Shokhijakhon Bekmuradov, an worker driver of provider Borderlanders Inc., crossed into the lane of oncoming site visitors on U.S. Route 160, a two-lane freeway. Nonetheless, in keeping with the recap by Decide Stephen McNamee, Bekmuradov didn’t instantly return to his regular lane.
A automotive heading the opposite manner and carrying Gregory Cox, his companion Lindsey Watson, and their three youngsters got here round a nook. That automotive collided headon with Bekmuradov’s truck. Cox and Watson had been killed and the three youngsters had been critically injured, in keeping with the recap.
The load was being shipped by medical tools provider Lincare which had employed J.B. Hunt’s brokerage arm to maneuver its merchandise. It was going from Denver to Phoenix, in keeping with the recap. (The worth of the load: $1,350). Borderlanders booked the load off the J.B. Hunt on-line dealer’s platform.
Two requests for dismissal
J.B. Hunt requested abstract judgment in its favor on two grounds. It sought a dismissal on the plaintiffs’ cost that it was vicariously responsible for the driving force’s actions and that Bekmuradov was a “statutory worker” of J.B. Hunt. It additionally sought dismissal on the plaintiffs’ cost that J.B. Hunt’s hiring of Borderlanders was negligent.
The provider/intermodal/brokerage big was profitable on the primary request. Nevertheless it was not profitable on the second request, and the case will go ahead.
J.B. Hunt (NASDAQ: JBHT) declined touch upon the case, citing the continuing litigation.
The unique protection put up by J.B. Hunt initially relied on the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (F4A) and its prohibition in opposition to state motion that may impression a “worth, route or service.” In its preliminary response within the case, which the plaintiffs had first filed in March 2024, J.B. Hunt additionally stated it couldn’t be introduced into the motion as a dealer as a result of the security exception to F4A, which does permit state motion on safety-related incidents if they’re “with respect to motor autos,” didn’t embrace brokers.
However that protection died with the ruling in Montgomery, forcing J.B. Hunt to search out completely different approaches.
The place J.B. Hunt failed in its argument, permitting the case to proceed, is Decide McNamee’s ruling that the plaintiffs “have offered adequate proof wherein a rational jury may discover that J.B. Hunt knew, or ought to have recognized, of the security dangers related in choosing Borderlanders to move the Load.”
The plaintiffs had argued that Borderlanders had a problematic previous. In an earlier submitting, it stated the provider had a “historical past of hiring inexperienced and incompetent drivers that put the motoring public prone to catastrophic harm or loss of life.” They stated J.B. Hunt ought to have recognized that when it employed Borderlanders.
Borderlanders isn’t a part of the motion earlier than the Arizona federal court docket. In response to the choose’s determination, the provider has settled with the plaintiffs and an motion in opposition to Bekmuradov was dismissed voluntarily with prejudice, ending the case.
That truth is a part of the J.B. Hunt argument in opposition to the negligent hiring declare. “J.B. Hunt contends that there stays no underlying tort declare in opposition to Borderlanders so Plaintiffs can not show an important aspect of their negligent hiring declare in opposition to J.B. Hunt,” Decide McNamee writes in his abstract.
Provider’s security report
J.B. Hunt, in keeping with the choose, has stated the plaintiffs haven’t supplied proof that Borderlanders had a checkered previous. However the choose didn’t settle for that.
“Plaintiffs cite proof that J.B. Hunt by no means reviewed Borderlanders’ publicly accessible accident and crash historical past, and FMCSA security scores, security evaluation alerts, and inspection violation historical past earlier than choosing Borderlanders,” the choose writes.
And he agreed. “There stay factual disputes concerning Plaintiffs’ negligent hiring declare in opposition to J.B. Hunt, due to this fact, the Court docket denies J.B. Hunt’s Movement on this declare,” Decide McNamee wrote.
What the court docket accepted
On the J.B. Hunt request for abstract judgment that was granted by the court docket, the corporate’s argument, in keeping with the choose’s submitting, is that it was “not liable underneath the federal leasing laws as a result of there was no lease between J.B. Hunt and Borderlanders.”
The court docket agreed with that view. “On this case, it’s undisputed that Borderlanders transported the Load underneath its personal authority utilizing its personal tools and driver,” the choose wrote. “Based mostly on the undisputed materials information, J.B. Hunt didn’t lease tools to Borderlanders. Thus, there isn’t a lease, and the federal leasing laws are inapplicable.”
These laws that may have held J.B. Hunt vicariously liable “apply provided that there’s a legitimate lease,” in keeping with the choice.
View from an outsider
Gregory Reed, a companion on the legislation agency of Hanson Bridgett and head of its transportation apply, stated in an e mail to BigRig that J.B. Hunt’s arguments had been “widespread refrains within the dealer and logistics business.” However he additionally described them as “unavailing.”
Reed summed up J.B. Hunt’s arguments.
One, in keeping with Reed, was that “Borderlanders remained a FMCSA-authorized (albeit unrated) provider thus brokers must be free to make use of such carriers insulated from negligence.”
That goes to the center of what quite a few business officers have argued within the wake of Montgomery: brokers lack tips on what steps they should take to guard themselves in opposition to negligent hiring claims in a lawsuit.
That was significantly stark within the current Texas nuclear verdict in opposition to C.H. Robinson, the place it was hit with a greater than $600 million verdict regardless of the provider it employed within the 2021 wreck that led to a few deaths had a Passable score from FMCSA.
That query of what constitutes adequate vetting isn’t as clear within the J.B. Hunt case, since Borderlanders, in keeping with quite a few references within the lawsuit’s varied briefs, didn’t have a stellar security report.
Reed stated the second argument by J.B. Hunt was that “Borderlanders’ security and efficiency report was inadequate to supply JB Hunt discover as a result of adverse incidents had been few in comparison with the provider’s variety of drivers and quantity of masses.”
With sufficient of J.B. Hunt’s arguments rejected that the case will proceed, a jury will be the subsequent step to take up the difficulty.
“Each (J.B. Hunt) arguments go to the obligation of care an organization like JB Hunt is required to train primarily based on what it ought to have recognized, and their failure at this stage within the case demonstrates that courts could also be unlikely to take these circumstances out of the fingers of the jury to find out reasonableness,” Reed stated.
Extra articles by John Kingston
SCOTUS motion revives shipper/receiver legal responsibility post-Montgomery
Denial of funds to NY over non domiciled CDLs overturned: appellate court docket
DOL sticks with impartial contractor proposal, trucking applauds
The publish J.B. Hunt dealer legal responsibility case continuing after cut up determination appeared first on BigRig.


