Forward of a Wednesday submitting deadline for public feedback, Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern used their third-quarter 2026 earnings calls to argue that their controversial proposed merger would decrease supply-chain prices and assist railroads win freight from vehicles.
Their opponents supplied totally different responses. CPKC (NYSE: CP) demanded rejection by the Floor Transportation Board; CSX (NASDAQ: CSX) emphasised partnerships, and CN (NYSE: CNI) highlighted an settlement meant to guard its enterprise whereas opening new markets.
BNSF, which as a unit of Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE: BRK-B) doesn’t maintain an earnings name, earlier supplied a public assertion from its chief government opposing the merger.
The STB is anticipated to render a choice in 2027.
Union Pacific: Decrease prices, quicker service and confidence in approval
On Union Pacific’s October 22 earnings name (NYSE: UNP), Chief Govt Jim Vena argued that combining the 2 networks would cut back the friction concerned in shifting freight between railroads.
“Our merger … will ship substantial measurable advantages by strengthening the provision chain,” Vena mentioned. “It’s going to decrease transportation prices and supply quicker, extra seamless rail service choices that allow our prospects to compete and assist hold items reasonably priced for American … customers.”
Vena characterised the transaction as an end-to-end mixture with restricted overlap, slightly than a consolidation of considerably parallel networks. He additionally pushed again towards opponents in search of concessions, saying requests wanted to be grounded within the merger’s precise aggressive results. Chief Monetary Officer Jennifer Hamann mentioned UP (NYSE: UNP) was constructing money reserves in anticipation of closing on the deal within the second half of 2027.
Norfolk Southern: Make truck-to-rail features everlasting
Norfolk Southern (NYSE: NSC) CEO Mark George framed the merger as a structural reply to an trade drawback. Freight can shift to rail when trucking turns into costly, then return to highways when market circumstances change.
“When shippers are given a rail product that provides higher worth than the freeway, they transfer freight to rail rapidly, and the Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern mixture is designed to create these circumstances completely,” George mentioned on the corporate’s October 22 earnings name.
George acknowledged that competing railroads had been already responding with new companies and nearer cooperation.
“We’ve positively seen a extra enhanced aggressive setting,” he mentioned, including that railroads working collectively was good for the trade even when it made competitors harder for Norfolk Southern. His argument was {that a} unified community might assist protect market-share features that in any other case may disappear as gasoline costs and trucking capability normalize.
CPKC: Reject the merger, slightly than cut price over concessions
CPKC CEO Keith Creel delivered essentially the most forceful earnings-call opposition, arguing that the proposed railroad’s scale and market energy would create dangers that had been pointless.
“We don’t desire a situation. We don’t desire a concession. We don’t suppose it’s wanted,” Creel mentioned throughout CPKC’s October 28 earnings name, reported by Trains. “To create one thing that represents that a lot danger, that a lot market energy endlessly is totally unneeded.”
Creel rejected comparisons with CPKC’s personal merger, stressing that Canadian Pacific and Kansas Metropolis Southern had been the 2 smallest Class I methods and remained the smallest mixed community. CPKC’s most well-liked consequence was rejection; if regulators nonetheless accepted the transaction, it might search protections together with aggressive entry and significant safeguards at interchange gateways.
CSX: Partnerships can enhance service with out widespread possession
On CSX’s October 21 earnings name, in response to a query relating to how the railroad’s partnerships with different carriers served as a counterweight to the proposed Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern mixture, Chief Business Officer Maryclare Kenney emphasised that cooperation throughout railroad boundaries was established observe, not a brand new response invented for the merger struggle.
“It’s been widespread observe for CSX to work intently with our interline companions to attempt to discover new and in some instances higher options for our prospects,” Kenney mentioned. “We’re at all times on the lookout for methods throughout our traces of enterprise—however I’d say particularly when you concentrate on intermodal—looking for options that enhance transit and enhance reliability for our prospects.”
Her reply centered on the business different to consolidation by connecting separate networks by service agreements. “We’ve been proud of the outcomes we’ve seen with the partnerships we fashioned during the last a number of years, and we’ll proceed to work on these going ahead,” she mentioned.
Canadian Nationwide: Shield the community and pursue Mexico development
Canadian Nationwide CEO Tracy Robinson described its potential settlement with Union Pacific as each a defensive measure and a development alternative.
“It mitigates the chance of the merger to our community and our enterprise, however it additionally creates alternatives,” Robinson mentioned on CN’s October 30 earnings name.
In her ready remarks, Robinson mentioned the “soon-to-be-finalized settlement” would lengthen CN’s attain into Mexico and place it to compete for a bigger share of roughly $45 billion in annual Canada–Mexico commerce. The settlement barters entry in alternate for CN dropping its opposition to the merger.
BNSF: A warning about charges and lowered competitors
BNSF President and CEO Katie Farmer opposed the transaction in a July 28 public assertion responding to supplemental merger data submitted to regulators.
“The extra knowledge submitted by UP doesn’t change the truth that this is able to be an anti-competitive transaction between two financially wholesome firms, that can increase charges on rail prospects and lead to increased costs for customers,” Farmer mentioned.
Why it issues: The result of the proposed merger is prone to reshape freight routings, interchange entry and aggressive leverage nicely past the 2 merging railroads.
Subscribe to BigRig’ Rail e-newsletter and get the newest insights on rail freight proper in your inbox.
Learn extra articles by Editor right here.
Learn extra:
Union Pacific police in shootout after alleged prepare theft on southern California freight line
BLET ends Wheeling & Lake Erie strike
Genesee & Wyoming prepares to separate into three rail holding firms
US rail visitors hits intermodal report as October freight features sign financial resilience, says AAR
Rising Q3 transportation prices squeeze producers, reward railroads and reshape commerce
The submit Transcontinental merger of Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern divides rail leaders appeared first on BigRig.


